Jim at the TipLine blog had a great idea that I'm going to pass along to my IT and district office people. Diigo student accounts should really be created by a source that will be present in student's lives beyond one school year. He says,
Why? Because, if I create the student accounts, they're not visible to other teachers. So, each teacher would have to upload their own list of students, causing them to have multiple accounts and causing their bookmarks to be scattered across those multiple accounts. A student should have the same account the entire time they're in that building, beit middle or high school.
Isn't this right on target? I hadn't thought of this but it's something worth considering. Right now my problem is that I'm one of the only teachers in my district that is attempting to use something like Diigo. No one else is really using it beyond their personal account??? and when I tell them about the cool possibilities I get answers like "Well, that is good for your kids because you are so techie, I would never do anything like that" or "Why would you invest so much time in this. I'm not doing anything until the IT people figure it out, then maybe I'd consider it".
It's one of the reason why I think it's important that a district have digital innovators down in the trenches. If you wait for an innovation to be embraced by district office people, it will be "deployed" as anything but innovative and will turn into a cookie cutter roll out. Now I get that it's good to have those for the masses of teachers who (embarassingly) pronounce their resistance to anything new or anything technological. I wouldn't even mind the cookie cutter rollout if it could happen in less than....5 years of investigation, research, planning and implementation. My students will be mid-way through HS before they figure out if it's a good thing to do!!!! I get it...but I'm saying there has to be more than the one mass model...allow for innovation around the edges and support that, too.
It's why I wish district deciders would figure out that they need to help us with these innovations and be more responsive when we don't know if it's the web application or our network...and not always assume it is the "other" guy. Who cares who's fault it is...it isn't about fault...it's about getting it to work so the kids can be invested and learn.
The reason why I'm investing this time is so that my kids can really interact with scientists and so they can use 21st century tools that are so embedded that it isn't about the technology. It's about the conversation around the science. I don't think my kids would even realize they are using some new fangled technology because it's just the way we started and done it from the beginning of school. we just had a protracted conversation about not giving up...why these scientists are willing to keep trying to make it work. My kids couldn't figure out why they hadn't given up...I guess pack up their stuff and sail home....and slowly they are beginning to realize that it's hard work. You have to hang in there if you want something badly enough. That you have to keep trying even if it's not working the first time, the second time and so on. This is not a lesson that they've encountered before and it's definitely not something with which they are familiar.
so many lessons from one activity...science, virtue of perseverance and oh yeah, technology.
